Selling put options: What market is suitable? How to balance risk and return

Image Source: pexels

In bullish, stable, or low-volatility markets, you can consider selling put options. The profit from this strategy primarily comes from the premium collected, but if the underlying asset’s price falls to zero, your maximum risk is the strike price minus the premium. Typically, the risk-reward ratio for this strategy is about 1:4.9, meaning you need to pay special attention to risk control. If you have a low risk tolerance and wish to buy stocks at a discount, this approach may be more suitable for you.

Key Points

• In bullish or stable markets, selling put options can generate steady profits with relatively low risk.
• In low-volatility environments, selling put options offers a higher annualized gross profit margin with relatively low risk.
• Choosing an appropriate strike price can balance risk and reward, requiring flexible adjustments based on market conditions.
• Capital management is key to controlling risk, ensuring sufficient cash reserves for each trade.
• Setting stop-losses can effectively limit losses, protecting the overall safety of your investment portfolio.

Suitable Market Conditions

Image Source: unsplash

Bullish or Stable Markets

In the U.S. market, if you expect the underlying asset’s price to rise or remain stable, selling put options is generally easier to profit from. In such conditions, the likelihood of the underlying asset’s price falling is low, reducing the risk of the option being exercised. You can generate steady income by collecting premiums.

Selling put options in bullish or stable markets allows you to buy quality stocks at a lower cost. If the underlying price does not fall below the strike price, you simply collect the premium without needing to purchase the stock.
Implied volatility significantly impacts your profits:

• When implied volatility is high, option prices rise, allowing you to collect higher premiums.
• If implied volatility decreases before expiration, the option’s value decreases, allowing you to buy back the option at a lower cost, maximizing profits.

Low Volatility Periods

In periods of low market volatility, the risk of selling put options is relatively low. U.S. market data shows that in low-volatility environments, related option strategies have higher annualized gross profit margins with lower volatility.

You can refer to the following data to understand performance in low-volatility environments:

• Since 2013, the volatility risk premium between the VIX and 30-day realized volatility has averaged 3.33%.
• The PUT Index has delivered an annualized return of +9.40% since July 1986, compared to +9.91% for the S&P 500 Index.
• The standard deviation of returns for the PUT Index is 10.26%, compared to 15.38% for the S&P 500 Index.

This data indicates that in low-volatility markets, selling put options can help you achieve relatively stable profits while bearing lower risk.

Low Downside Risk Environments

In market environments with low downside risk, selling put options is safer. You can assess whether downside risk is low by observing key indicators.

You can combine these indicators to determine if the current market is suitable for selling put options. If the PCR is low and the RSI is in a neutral range, it suggests limited downside risk, allowing you to adopt this strategy with greater confidence.

How Selling Put Options Works

Premium Income

When you sell a put option, you first receive a premium. This premium is your direct reward for taking on risk. The size of the premium depends on the underlying asset’s price, strike price, expiration date, and market volatility. You can think of the premium as an “insurance fee”—as long as the underlying price remains above the strike price at expiration, you keep the entire premium.

By collecting premiums, you gain a steady cash flow. Many investors choose to sell put options during high volatility because premiums are higher.

Profit and Loss Structure at Expiration

You need to understand the profit and loss structure of selling put options. At expiration, if the underlying price is above the strike price, you keep the entire premium. If the underlying price falls below the strike price, you must buy the underlying asset at the strike price, incurring a loss equal to the strike price minus the underlying price, minus the premium received.
You can refer to the following table to compare the profit and risk of selling put options versus buying call options:

• The profit from selling put options is limited to the premium, but the risk can be significant.
• The profit from buying call options is also limited, but the risk is confined to the premium.

Buying Stocks at a Discount

When selling put options, you can also buy the underlying stock at a lower price. If the underlying price falls below the strike price, you are required to buy the stock at the strike price. Since you have already collected the premium, your actual purchase cost is lower than the market price.

You can think of this approach as “buying quality assets at a discount.” If you already plan to buy a particular stock, selling put options can help you reduce the purchase cost while increasing profit opportunities.

Risk Analysis

Image Source: pexels

Maximum Loss Scenario

When selling put options, you must understand the source of maximum loss. If the underlying asset’s price suddenly drops to zero, you must buy the asset at the strike price. The premium you received can only offset part of the loss. The calculation of maximum loss is straightforward:

• The maximum potential loss from selling put options is your obligation to purchase the asset at the strike price.
• If the underlying asset’s price drops to zero, your loss equals the strike price minus the premium received.

For example, if you sell a put option with a USD 50 strike price and receive a USD 2 premium, if the underlying price drops to zero, your maximum loss is USD 50 - USD 2 = USD 48 per share. While this extreme scenario is rare, you must prepare a risk plan in advance.

In practice, you should focus on the risk-reward ratio. Professional traders recommend a risk-reward ratio of at least 1:3. You can refer to the following table for recommended risk-reward ratios for different trading durations:

When selecting option contracts, prioritize opportunities with a risk-reward ratio above 1:3 to better protect your capital.

Leverage and Margin

When selling put options, you typically need to post margin. Margin requirements and leverage directly affect your risk level. You can understand their impact through the following points:

• Margin requirements and leverage determine the amount of capital you must maintain in your account to cover potential losses.
• Higher leverage can amplify your profits but also your losses, increasing overall risk.
• Option margin is the amount you need to deposit with your broker to cover potential losses from option positions.

In actual trading, it’s advisable to control leverage ratios reasonably to avoid forced liquidation due to insufficient margin. You can regularly check your account funds to ensure sufficient margin to handle market fluctuations.

Balancing Reward and Risk

Capital Management

When selling put options, capital management is the first step in controlling risk. You need to reserve sufficient cash for each trade to cover the obligation to buy the underlying asset if the price falls below the strike price. This prevents being forced to buy large amounts of stock during sudden market downturns, which could strain your account.
You can adopt various capital allocation strategies:

You can further reduce risk through position sizing, diversification, and stop-loss orders. You can also implement hedging strategies to protect your portfolio from extreme market fluctuations.

When selling put options, it’s recommended to prioritize conservative or moderate capital management approaches to ensure a single trade does not significantly impact your overall assets.

Strike Price Selection

When choosing a strike price, you need to balance risk and reward. Lower strike prices typically offer lower premiums but higher risk; higher strike prices provide more downside protection but increase premium income. You should decide the strike price based on your confidence in the underlying asset’s stability or growth potential.

You can refer to the following suggestions:

• Choose a strike price that reflects your judgment of the stock’s future movement.
• At-the-money (ATM) or slightly out-of-the-money (OTM) put options are generally more popular, balancing risk and premium income.
• Higher strike prices yield more premium but also increase risk. You need to choose based on your risk tolerance.

In practice, you can adjust the strike price flexibly based on market volatility and your financial situation. This helps control potential losses while optimizing the profit structure.

Stop-Loss Settings

When selling put options, stop-loss settings are a critical tool for protecting capital. You can adjust stop-loss levels based on market volatility. In high-volatility environments, set wider stop-loss ranges to avoid frequent triggering.
You can adopt the following methods:

• Calculate stop-loss based on option premium and risk tolerance. For example, with an option price of USD 5 and a 20% risk tolerance, set the stop-loss at USD 4.
• Avoid setting overly tight stop-losses on high-volatility options to prevent amplified losses from frequent triggering.
• Dynamically adjust stop-loss ranges based on market conditions to adapt to different environments.
• Test different stop-loss strategies in a demo account to find the most suitable approach.

By setting stop-losses reasonably, you can effectively limit the maximum loss per trade, protecting the overall safety of your portfolio.

Combination Strategies

You can combine selling put options with other option strategies to enhance portfolio returns and safety. Common combinations include:

• Selling put options with covered call options: You can collect premiums from both, generating dual income.
• Collar Strategy: While holding stocks, sell put options to earn additional premiums and buy protective put options to reduce risk.
• Iron Condor Strategy: In range-bound markets, sell both put and call options to profit from premiums when market volatility is low.

By combining different strategies, you can diversify risk and enhance overall returns. You can also adjust strategy structures flexibly based on market conditions and personal goals.

In practice, it’s advisable to test combination strategies with small capital first, gradually gaining experience to avoid unnecessary losses from operational errors.

When balancing reward and risk, beware of common mistakes, such as lacking understanding of options, improper risk management, choosing the wrong options, emotional decision-making, or execution errors. You should also pay attention to psychological factors, stay rational, and avoid irrational decisions driven by fear or greed.

By improving emotional intelligence and trading discipline, you can reduce cognitive biases, maintain objective judgment, and optimize the overall performance of selling put options.

Selling Put Options Case Study

Profit and Loss Calculation

When selling put options, you can calculate the profit and loss for each trade using the following steps:

1. You need to understand the basic profit and loss formula. The maximum profit equals the premium received.
2. If the underlying asset’s price at expiration is above the strike price, you achieve the maximum profit, keeping the entire premium.
3. If the underlying price drops to zero, your maximum loss is the strike price minus the premium received.
4. You can calculate the breakeven point: the strike price minus the premium received is the breakeven point.

For example, if you sell a put option with a USD 50 strike price and receive a USD 3 premium, if the underlying price at expiration is above USD 50, you keep the entire premium. If the price drops to USD 47, you break even. If the price drops to zero, you lose USD 47 per share.

In practice, it’s advisable to sell put options only on assets you are willing to hold and ensure your account has sufficient funds to meet potential purchase obligations. You can monitor the underlying asset’s price and consider setting stop-loss orders to limit risk.

Comparison Across Market Conditions

The results of selling put options vary significantly across different market environments:

• In stable or rising markets, you can typically keep the premium received, achieving maximum profit.
• If the market declines, especially if the underlying price falls below the strike price, you may need to buy the stock at a price higher than the market, facing potential losses.
• Time decay works in your favor, as the option’s value decreases over time, allowing you to close the position early for a profit.

You can refer to the following table to understand the historical performance of selling put options in the U.S. market during high-volatility periods:

In actual trading, you need to monitor market trends and manage capital wisely, leveraging the advantage of time decay. You can further control risk by monitoring asset prices and setting stop-loss orders.

Before selling put options, you need to focus on the following key factors:

• You collect option premiums as income, but if you expect the stock price to fall, you should not use this strategy.
• Selling options means you are obligated to buy the stock at the strike price, which could lead to losses if the market price is lower.

You should continue learning the basics of options, understanding strike prices, expiration dates, and contract types. You can control each trade’s position size to 2-5% and implement stop-loss strategies. You can also track win rates, risk-reward ratios, and maximum drawdowns to optimize your trading plan.
You can refer to the following courses to improve your skills:

You should trade rationally based on your risk tolerance and avoid blindly chasing premiums. Continuous learning and strategy optimization will help achieve long-term stable profits.

FAQ

How much capital is needed to sell put options?

You need to prepare sufficient cash or margin. Typically, you must have enough funds to buy 100 shares of the underlying stock at the strike price. For example, with a USD 50 strike price, you need USD 5,000.

What if I want to close the position before expiration?

You can buy back the sold put option on the market at any time. This allows you to lock in profits or reduce losses early. You only need to pay the current option price.

Will selling put options lead to forced exercise?

If the underlying price falls below the strike price, the buyer may exercise the option. You will need to buy the stock at the strike price. Ensure your account has sufficient funds to handle this situation.

How does selling put options differ from buying stocks?

When selling put options, you collect a premium upfront. You only need to buy the stock if the price falls below the strike price. Buying stocks directly does not provide premium income.

Is selling put options suitable for beginners?

You need to understand option basics and risk management. Beginners can practice with a demo account to familiarize themselves with the process. Avoid blindly chasing premiums.

By understanding when to sell put options and manage risks, you’re equipped to capture premium income in bullish or stable markets, but high cross-border fees, currency volatility, and offshore account complexities can hinder trading U.S. options, especially for swift responses to low-volatility setups or margin management. Picture a platform with 0.5% remittance fees, same-day global transfers, and contract limit orders with zero fees, enabling seamless put-selling strategies via one account?

BiyaPay is tailored for options sellers, offering instant fiat-to-digital conversions to act on market signals nimbly. With real-time exchange rate query, monitor USD trends and transfer at optimal moments to cut costs. Covering most regions with instant arrivals, it powers rapid allocations to S&P 500 index puts (like SPY) or individual stock puts. Crucially, trade U.S. and Hong Kong markets through a single account, leveraging contract limit orders with zero fees for VIX or PCR-based limit strategies.

Whether chasing steady premiums or optimizing risk control, BiyaPay fuels your precision. Sign up now, visit stocks for U.S. prospects—quick setup unlocks cost-effective, data-driven trading. Join global investors and triumph in 2025 markets!