Is swing trading really easier to make big profits than long-term trading?

Image Source: unsplash

You might wonder whether swing trading is easier for making big money compared to long-term investing. In fact, both approaches have their own advantages. In swing trading, you can seize short-term opportunities from market fluctuations. Data shows that only about 10% of swing traders achieve consistent profits. In contrast, the success rate for long-term investing lacks clear statistics.

You need to weigh which approach suits you best based on your goals and capabilities.

Key Points

• Swing trading suits investors who can tolerate short-term fluctuations, with a success rate of about 10%.
• Long-term investing is better for those seeking stable growth, typically requiring lower risk tolerance.
• Swing trading can capitalize on short-term market fluctuations for high returns, but it also carries higher risks.
• When choosing an investment approach, considering your time, risk tolerance, and mental resilience is crucial.
• Effective risk management strategies can help you survive and profit in volatile markets.

Swing Trading vs. Long-Term Investing

Image Source: pexels

Introduction to Swing Trading

You can understand swing trading as a strategy that profits from short-term market fluctuations. You hold stocks or other assets for a few days to weeks, aiming to earn profits by buying low and selling high. The table below summarizes the standard definition of swing trading from financial literature:

Introduction to Long-Term Investing

In long-term investing, you choose to hold stocks or assets for months or even years. You focus on a company’s fundamentals and industry trends rather than short-term price fluctuations. You aim to achieve natural asset value growth over time. Long-term investors typically trade less frequently, emphasizing patience and discipline.

Key Differences

You can quickly distinguish swing trading from long-term investing through the following points:

• Swing trading has a holding period of a few days to weeks with moderate trading frequency.
• Long-term investing has a holding period of months to years with low trading frequency.
• Swing traders focus more on technical analysis and market fluctuations, while long-term investors prioritize fundamental analysis and long-term trends.

You can choose the investment approach that better suits you based on your time, energy, and risk preferences.

Swing Trading Profits and Risks

Image Source: unsplash

Profit Opportunities

In swing trading, you can capitalize on short-term market fluctuations to generate profits. Historical data shows that swing trading strategies can achieve an annualized return of 79.4%. The table below shows the annualized returns for different strategies:

You can see that swing trading has high profit potential. Market volatility provides opportunities for price swings. You can use 4-hour, daily, or weekly charts to identify market trends. When the market shows a new trend or breaks through key support and resistance levels, you have a chance to capture profits. Economic data releases and major reports also bring significant volatility, allowing you to make quick decisions by closely monitoring the market.

In practice, you can use real-time data, technical indicators, and alert systems to identify trading opportunities. For example, in EUR/USD swing trading, traders using daily charts and technical patterns achieved a +85-point profit in 10 days. You can also use built-in screeners and advanced charting tools to select qualifying stocks or assets.

Swing trading typically has a higher survival rate than short-term trading. Industry data indicates that swing traders’ success rates range from 35% to 50%, with per-trade returns ranging from 12% to 45%. In contrast, short-term traders face higher loss ratios. If you maintain discipline and risk management, you have a chance to survive long-term in the market.

Tip: When swing trading, focusing on trends, support and resistance, technical analysis, and risk management is critical. Only then can you seize more opportunities in volatile markets.

Risk Characteristics

While pursuing high profits, you also face various risks in swing trading. First, overnight and weekend price gaps may render your stop-loss ineffective, leading to unexpected losses. If you neglect risk management, a single mistake could result in significant capital loss. You should avoid putting all your funds into one trade; diversification can help reduce risks.

Swing trading’s higher trading frequency means commissions and fees can quickly erode your profits. You must pay a certain transaction fee for each trade, and frequent trading can offset small gains with costs. You also need to consider short-term capital gains taxes, which further reduce your net returns. Generally, you need at least $10,000 in starting capital to effectively mitigate the impact of trading costs.

In swing trading, you need to continuously monitor market data. You rely on real-time quotes, technical indicators, and risk management tools. Only then can you promptly identify market changes and minimize losses. You also need to adjust strategies in bull, bear, and range-bound markets. In bull markets, you can more easily find buying opportunities; in bear markets, traditional holding strategies may fail, requiring flexible responses.

In contrast, long-term investing has unique advantages. You can harness the power of compounding to achieve exponential asset growth. Long-term holding smooths out short-term market fluctuations, reducing costs and taxes from frequent trading. You can also lower overall risk through a diversified portfolio. Historical data shows that long-term investors typically benefit from the market’s long-term upward trend. While markets experience periodic downturns, major U.S. market indices have mostly risen over decades, offering you a higher probability of success.

You can refer to the following real-world cases:

• John improved profitability by 30% through real-time signals for short-term trading.
• Michael used swing trading and real-time signals to achieve more stable profits and fewer losses.
• Sarah achieved significant long-term gains through long-term investing in the technology sector.

When choosing between swing trading and long-term investing, you need to weigh profits against risks. Swing trading offers high returns but comes with greater risks and operational challenges. You must make rational choices based on your experience, capital, and risk tolerance.

Advantages and Disadvantages

Swing Trading Pros and Cons

When choosing swing trading, you can enjoy high flexibility and more trading opportunities. The table below summarizes the main advantages of swing trading:

However, swing trading also has clear disadvantages:

• You need substantial market experience to accuratelyinsecurately judge buying and selling opportunities.
• You must continuously monitor market changes and adjust strategies promptly.
• High market volatility can lead to unexpected losses.
• Frequent trading may increase fees, eroding some profits.
• Emotional stress persists, especially during consecutive losses, which can affect decision-making.

Long-Term Investing Pros and Cons

If you choose long-term investing, you can enjoy the following benefits:

• Long-term holding helps improve corporate governance, curbing short-sighted management behavior.
• You can enhance profitability and reduce risk through time accumulation.
• Long-term investors’ continuous oversight helps protect shareholders’ long-term interests.

However, long-term investing also has drawbacks:

• You may miss short-term market opportunities.
• Long-term holding during market downturns can lead to significant losses.
• Choosing one investment approach means forgoing potential gains from another, which is an opportunity cost.

Operational Difficulty and Mental Stress

In swing trading, you need to actively monitor the market and perform technical analysis. You must invest more time and energy, facing higher short-term risks. You also need to make quick decisions, maintaining high discipline and patience.

Long-term investing is more passive; you only need to periodically check your portfolio. You need patience to wait for market returns and trust in your investment choices. While market fluctuations bring mental stress, you only need to resist the temptation of short-term volatility and stick to long-term goals.

Investor Choices

Suitable Investors

When choosing an investment approach, you should first understand your personality and behavioral traits. Successful long-term investors typically have the following characteristics:

• You have strong adaptability and confidence in facing setbacks.
• You are ambitious, enjoying challenges and competition.
• You make decisions directly and decisively, less influenced by others.
• You are cautious and skilled at creating detailed plans.
• You are curious about new knowledge, enjoying research and analysis.

Your values also influence investment choices. If you view money as a source of security, you may lean toward conservative investing. If you see money as a tool to achieve goals, you may be more willing to take risks and try different investment approaches.

Selection Recommendations

When deciding between swing trading and long-term investing, you need to consider the following key factors:

1. How much risk are you willing to take? Swing trading carries higher risks, suitable for those who can tolerate short-term fluctuations. Long-term investing has lower risks, better for those seeking stable growth.
2. How much time can you commit? If you have ample time to monitor the market, swing trading may suit you. If time is limited, long-term investing is more hassle-free.
3. What is your mental resilience? Short-term trading requires quick decisions and handling frequent gains and losses. Long-term investing tests your patience and discipline.

You can refer to the table below to understand the goals and risk tolerance of different investment approaches:

Tip: When choosing an investment approach, make rational judgments based on your experience, goals, and risk tolerance, avoiding blind trend-following.

When choosing between swing trading and long-term investing, there is no absolute answer to “making big money.” You need to make rational judgments based on your experience, goals, and risk tolerance. You can manage risks through the following methods:

• Control the position size of each trade, typically not exceeding 1% to 2% of total capital.
• Set a reasonable risk-reward ratio, targeting at least 1:2.
• Use stop-loss orders to avoid significant losses.

By prioritizing risk management, you can go further in the market.

FAQ

Which is more suitable for beginners, swing trading or long-term investing?

If you’re new to investing, it’s recommended to start with long-term investing. It requires less experience and has more manageable risks. You can gradually build knowledge and confidence.

How much starting capital is needed for swing trading?

You typically need at least $10,000 as starting capital. This allows risk diversification and reduces the impact of single trades on overall funds.

Can swing trading be done full-time?

You can do swing trading full-time, but it requires continuous learning and market monitoring. You also need stable mental resilience and strict risk management.

How often should you check your account for long-term investing?

You can check your portfolio quarterly or semi-annually. This allows timely strategy adjustments while avoiding emotional fluctuations from frequent operations.

Can swing trading and long-term investing be done simultaneously?

You can adopt both strategies simultaneously. This diversifies risks and leverages different market opportunities. However, you need to allocate funds and energy reasonably.

By dissecting swing trading versus long-term investing, you’ve grasped their profit potential and risk profiles, but high cross-border fees, currency volatility, and complex account setups can limit swift responses to U.S. market swings or long-term trends, especially during key support breaks or economic data releases. Imagine a platform with 0.5% remittance fees, same-day global transfers, and zero-fee limit orders, enabling seamless swing or long-term strategies via one account?

BiyaPay is tailored for multi-strategy investors, offering instant fiat-to-digital conversions to act on market signals nimbly. With real-time exchange rate query, monitor USD trends and transfer at optimal moments to cut costs. Covering most regions with instant arrivals, it powers rapid allocations to S&P 500 ETFs (like SPY) or high-volatility tech stocks. Crucially, trade U.S. and Hong Kong markets through a single account, leveraging zero-fee limit orders for technical indicator-based swing trades or fundamentals-driven long-term holds.

Whether chasing short-term gains or steady growth, BiyaPay fuels your edge. Sign up now, visit stocks for U.S. prospects—quick setup unlocks cost-effective, data-driven investing. Join global investors and thrive in 2025’s markets!