Synthetic Put Option: A Comprehensive Analysis of a Risk-Hedging Strategy for Protecting Short Positions

Image Source: pexels

When engaging in short selling, you often worry about sudden market rebounds causing significant losses. The synthetic put option provides an effective risk-hedging tool. By shorting the underlying asset and simultaneously buying a call option with the same strike price, you can lock in a minimum selling price, limit potential losses, and confidently navigate market volatility.

Key Takeaways

• The synthetic put option, through shorting the underlying asset and buying a call option, helps investors limit the maximum loss of a short position.
• In markets with heightened volatility or low liquidity for standard put options, the synthetic put option offers a flexible risk management tool.
• When constructing a synthetic put option, selecting highly liquid underlyings and contracts is critical to reducing transaction costs and risks.
• Investors should focus on the breakeven point of the synthetic put option to assess the strategy’s effectiveness and potential returns.
• When implementing a synthetic put option strategy, regularly evaluate market changes and adjust the strategy promptly to address risks.

Synthetic Put Option Protection Mechanism

Image Source: pexels

Risk Hedging Principle

When shorting stocks, your biggest concern is often the unlimited loss risk from a sudden market rebound. The synthetic put option, through the combination of “shorting the underlying + buying a call option,” establishes a protective barrier for your short position. While shorting the stock, you buy a call option with the same strike price and expiration date. This way, even if the underlying asset’s price surges, you can exercise the call option to buy back the stock at a fixed price, thereby locking in the maximum loss.

The theoretical basis of this strategy lies in the synthetic put option’s risk-reward structure, which closely resembles that of a standard put option. You can refer to the table below to understand the construction methods and advantages of different synthetic positions:

Through the synthetic put option, you can effectively limit the maximum loss of a short position, avoiding significant losses due to sudden market reversals. This risk-hedging mechanism is particularly suitable for use during periods of heightened market volatility or uncertainty.

Applicable Scenarios

The synthetic put option is not suitable for all market conditions. You need to assess whether to adopt this strategy based on specific circumstances. The protective role of the synthetic put option is particularly prominent in the following scenarios:

• Market environments where traditional put options have low liquidity or are expensive
• Markets where stock prices are expected to decline or volatility is increasing
• Periods of low implied volatility, with expectations of rising volatility in the future
• Market environments with regulatory or margin constraints

When operating in the U.S. market, if you find that standard put options are overpriced or have limited trading volume, you can consider using a synthetic put option instead. You can also use this strategy to lock in maximum losses when expecting a short-term market decline but fearing a rebound. The synthetic put option provides a flexible risk management tool, helping you navigate complex and volatile market environments with stability.

Synthetic Put Option Definition and Principle

Strategy Structure

You can construct a synthetic put option in two simple steps. This strategy allows you to achieve a risk-reward structure similar to a standard put option without directly purchasing one. The specific steps are as follows:

• Short the underlying stock. For example, you short 100 shares of AAPL in the U.S. market at $215 per share.
• Simultaneously buy a call option with the same strike price. You can purchase an AAPL call option with a $215 strike price, assuming the option price is $6 per share.

This combination allows you to profit when the stock price falls, as your short position gains. If AAPL’s price rises, you can exercise the call option to buy back the stock at $215, limiting losses. You need to note that shorting the stock generates initial cash inflow but requires margin.

Through the synthetic put option, you can flexibly achieve risk hedging when liquidity is low or standard put options are overpriced.

Risk-Reward Characteristics

The risk-reward structure of a synthetic put option closely resembles that of a standard put option. You can refer to the table below for a clear overview of its main characteristics:

When using a synthetic put option, the maximum loss equals the premium paid for the call option. For example, if you pay $6 per share for an AAPL call option, the maximum loss is $6 per share. As long as AAPL’s price falls below $209 ($215 - $6), you start to profit. The strategy generates positive initial cash flow, but you need to monitor margin changes and the option’s expiration date continuously.

Comparison with Standard Put Option

When choosing a risk-hedging tool, you often compare the synthetic put option with a standard put option. The two differ in structure and risk exposure:

• Synthetic options replicate the payoff structure of a standard put option through shorting the stock and buying a call option.
• A standard put option directly grants you the right to sell the underlying asset at a specific price, making it simpler to execute.
• Synthetic put options may involve higher complexity and margin requirements. You need to manage the short position, monitor borrowing costs, and track margin changes.
• Synthetic options may have higher risk exposure, with stricter margin and liquidity requirements during market volatility.

In practice, you should choose the appropriate hedging tool based on market liquidity, option prices, and your risk tolerance.

Strategy Construction

Tools and Contract Selection

When constructing a synthetic put option, you should prioritize selecting highly liquid U.S. stocks as the underlying. You can operate through standard stock and option contracts on major U.S. exchanges. Choosing the right call option contract is critical. You should focus on the following aspects:

• Strike Price: Select a strike price that matches or is close to your shorting price to better replicate the protective effect of a standard put option.
• Expiration Date: Choose an expiration date that aligns with your risk exposure to ensure coverage throughout the short position’s duration.
• Contract Liquidity: High-liquidity option contracts help reduce bid-ask spreads and transaction costs.
• Margin Requirements: Understand the margin requirements for shorting stocks and ensure sufficient account funds.

If you want to further optimize the risk-reward structure, you can adjust the strike prices of call and put options to form a collar strategy. At this point, the put option’s strike price sets the floor for potential losses, while the call option’s strike price caps potential gains. The choice of strike prices directly impacts the overall risk and reward.

Operational Process

You can follow these steps to construct a synthetic put option:

1. Select the target stock and short it in the U.S. market. For example, you short 100 shares of AAPL at $215 per share.
2. Choose a call option with a strike price matching or close to the shorting price, ensuring the expiration date covers your short position’s duration.
3. Purchase the call option through a brokerage platform to complete the synthetic put option setup.
4. Continuously monitor market prices and margin changes, adjusting the option position or strike price as needed based on market volatility.

During the process, ensure each step complies with exchange and brokerage regulations to avoid additional risks due to operational errors.

Considerations

When executing a synthetic put option strategy, you need to focus on the following key points to avoid common pitfalls:

• Conduct comprehensive market analysis to assess risks and opportunities.
• Select appropriate options to ensure strategy effectiveness.
• Execute the strategy at the right time to avoid unnecessary costs.
• Implement effective risk management measures to protect investment safety.
• Continuously monitor market changes and adjust the strategy promptly.
• Pay attention to time decay’s impact on option value to avoid diminishing protection.
• Avoid implementing the strategy during low volatility to prevent increased costs.
• Control option protection costs to prevent excessive premiums from eroding strategy returns.
• Adjust strike prices or expiration dates promptly based on market changes to ensure protection effectiveness.

Only by fully understanding the risks and rewards of each step can you effectively use the synthetic put option for risk hedging.

Risk and Reward

Image Source: unsplash

Breakeven Point

When using a synthetic put option, the breakeven point is key to determining the strategy’s success. The breakeven point is influenced by the option’s net premium, strike price, and price movements of the underlying asset. You can refer to the table below to understand these factors:

In practice, as long as the underlying asset’s price falls below the breakeven point, the strategy is profitable. If it rises above the breakeven point, you will incur losses.

Maximum Profit and Loss

The synthetic put option’s maximum profit and loss structure is clear. You can refer to the table below to compare the risk-reward of different strategies:

When shorting, the synthetic put option helps you lock in the maximum loss. Even if the market surges, you only bear the call option’s premium and the difference between the strike price and the current price. In contrast, a bearish put spread has lower maximum losses but also limited profits.

Cost Analysis

When implementing a synthetic put option strategy, you need to consider multiple costs, including margin, transaction fees, and the cost of shorting stocks. The table below summarizes these costs:

When operating in the U.S. market, controlling costs reasonably helps improve overall returns. You should regularly assess margin changes to avoid liquidity risks from additional margin calls. Choosing high-liquidity option contracts can also effectively reduce transaction fees.

Case Study and Profit/Loss

Market Scenarios

When operating in the U.S. market, you often encounter heightened volatility or low liquidity. The synthetic put option strategy performs well in these scenarios. For example, investor Alex effectively protected their portfolio by creating a synthetic short position, avoiding significant losses during a market downturn. You can also use a similar approach, leveraging synthetic forward contracts to hedge short-term position losses, lock in borrowing costs, and reduce the risk of being forced to return borrowed stocks.
The table below outlines common market cases and their descriptions:

Profit/Loss Calculation

In practice, you need to clearly understand the profit and loss under different market scenarios. The table below illustrates the profit/loss calculation for a synthetic put option strategy under three typical market scenarios:

You can see that the synthetic put option strategy effectively limits maximum losses while generating significant profits when the underlying price falls. By monitoring the option premium and strike price changes, you can quickly assess profit and loss.

Strategy Optimization

When facing changes in market volatility, you can flexibly adjust the synthetic put option strategy. The following methods can help optimize the risk-reward structure:

• Convert to a synthetic straddle strategy to profit from increased volatility.
• Use synthetic covered calls to generate additional income while managing downside risk.
• In neutral or volatile markets, implement synthetic straddles or protective strategies to hedge risks or capture opportunities from price fluctuations.

By continuously optimizing the strategy structure, you can achieve higher risk control and return objectives in different market environments.

Market Applications and Discussion

Current Opportunities

In the U.S. market, you often encounter heightened volatility or low liquidity for standard put options. The synthetic put option provides a flexible risk management tool, especially suitable when traditional put options are hard to obtain or expensive. You can refer to the table below to understand the main application opportunities for synthetic put options in the current market:

You can use synthetic put options to protect short positions during market volatility, reducing risks from sudden rebounds. In markets with limited option liquidity, you can also choose synthetic strategies to achieve risk hedging.

Common Questions

In practice, you may encounter various questions about synthetic put options. The table below summarizes the aspects investors are most concerned about, helping you better understand and apply the strategy:

When choosing a synthetic put option, focus on maximum loss, breakeven point, and strategy validity period. You also need to allocate positions reasonably based on your risk tolerance.

Limitations

When using a synthetic put option, you must understand its differences and limitations compared to a standard put option. The table below compares the main characteristics of the two in practical applications:

In practice, you may face high margin requirements, operational complexity, and liquidity constraints. You also need to monitor the impact of call option price fluctuations on the overall strategy. You should weigh the pros and cons of synthetic and standard put options based on your needs and market conditions to choose the most suitable risk-hedging tool.

Through the synthetic put option, you can effectively protect short positions and reduce risks from sudden price surges. This strategy, combining short selling and a long call option, is suitable for novice investors and enables capital protection. In practice, you should focus on option costs, margin requirements, and market volatility. Recent U.S. market cases show that risk reversal strategies perform exceptionally well in volatile environments:

You should rationally assess your needs, continuously learn about options, adjust strategies flexibly, and enhance risk management capabilities.

FAQ

What is the difference between a synthetic put option and a standard put option?

With a synthetic put option, you need to short the underlying asset and buy a call option simultaneously. A standard put option only requires a direct purchase. Both have similar risk-reward structures, but the operational process and costs differ.

What risks should I watch for when implementing a synthetic put option?

You need to monitor margin changes, borrowing costs, and option liquidity. During high market volatility, the risk of additional margin calls increases. Call option price fluctuations also affect the overall protection effect.

Which market environments are suitable for synthetic put options?

You can choose synthetic put options when standard put options have low liquidity or are expensive. This strategy is suitable for high-volatility or short-term rebound-expected U.S. markets.

What are the main components of the strategy’s costs?

You need to pay the call option premium, bear the borrowing costs for shorting stocks, and meet the brokerage’s margin requirements. Transaction fees also affect overall costs.

How do I handle a synthetic put option position at expiration?

You can choose to close the position or exercise the option. If the underlying price rises, you exercise the call option to buy back the stock. If the price falls, you buy back the stock in the market, profiting from the short position.

You’ve mastered the Synthetic Put strategy, recognizing that when taking a short position in the US stock market, capital mobility and cost efficiency are crucial for success. Whether it’s paying the call option premium or managing the short position’s margin, high remittance fees and non-transparent exchange rates from traditional cross-border services can undermine your hedge gains.

BiyaPay is here to provide you with efficient and low-cost global financial services. We offer real-time exchange rate inquiry and conversion for fiat currencies, with remittance fees as low as 0.5%, ensuring every fund transfer is transparent and highly cost-effective. A key advantage is our zero commission for contract limit orders, further optimizing your trading expenses. Furthermore, BiyaPay supports the conversion between various fiat and cryptocurrencies, allowing you to trade Stocks, options, and other global assets all on one platform. There is no need for a complex overseas account, and your funds can be remitted and arrive within the same day. Click the Real-time Exchange Rate Inquiry now, BiyaPay for quick registration, and use superior cost management and funding speed to make your risk-hedging strategy even more robust!