ETFs and Mutual Funds: A Comprehensive Comparison for Investors

Image Source: unsplash

You often encounter ETFs and mutual funds when making investment choices. Both differ significantly in structure, trading methods, and fees. An increasing number of U.S. retail investors favor ETFs, with 45% of investors holding ETFs in 2024. The table below shows the change in ETF usage over recent years:

These data reflect the shifting popularity of ETFs and mutual funds among investors.

Key Points

• ETFs generally have lower fees, suitable for investors seeking low-cost investments. Mutual funds have higher fees, suitable for those willing to pay more for professional management.
• ETFs are traded in real-time on exchanges, offering greater flexibility. Mutual funds can only be traded at the net asset value (NAV) after the trading day ends, lacking flexibility.
• ETFs have high transparency, disclosing holdings daily. Mutual funds typically disclose quarterly, with less frequent updates compared to ETFs.
• When choosing investment vehicles, clarify your investment style. Actively managed mutual funds suit investors willing to research markets, while ETFs suit those seeking market-average performance.
• For long-term investments, both ETFs and mutual funds are viable; for short-term needs, prioritize ETFs with higher liquidity for quick fund adjustments.

Core Differences Between ETFs and Mutual Funds

Structure and Management

When choosing collective investment vehicles, you first need to understand their structure and management style. ETFs and mutual funds differ significantly in management style and legal structure:

• Most ETFs adopt passive management, tracking specific indices, such as the S&P 500. When you invest in an ETF, the fund manager does not frequently trade assets but aims to replicate the index’s performance.
• Mutual funds are often actively managed. Fund managers actively trade stocks or bonds based on market judgment and research, striving to achieve above-market returns.

The table below summarizes the main differences in structure and management:

You can see that ETFs are better suited for tracking overall market performance with higher tax efficiency. Mutual funds rely more on the fund manager’s active decisions, suitable for investors seeking above-average returns.

Trading Methods

ETFs and mutual funds differ significantly in trading methods. When you invest in an ETF, you can trade it in real-time on an exchange, like stocks. ETF prices fluctuate with market supply and demand, allowing you to flexibly choose the timing for buying and selling. You can also use various order types, such as market orders or limit orders.

Mutual funds are different. You can only purchase or redeem them at the net asset value (NAV) after the trading day ends. Regardless of when you place an order during the day, the final transaction price is based on the closing NAV, lacking flexibility.

The table below compares their trading mechanisms:

If you need flexibility to adjust your portfolio, ETFs’ trading methods are more suitable. Mutual funds are better for long-term holdings, suitable for investors who do not need frequent trading.

Fees and Transparency

When investing, fees and transparency directly impact your returns. ETFs and mutual funds differ significantly in these areas.

• ETFs generally have lower fees. In the U.S. market, passively managed ETFs have average expense ratios between 0.03% and 0.3%. The median expense ratio for index ETFs is 0.56%.
• Mutual funds typically have higher fees, with actively managed funds’ expense ratios ranging from 0.5% to 1%. The median expense ratio for index mutual funds is 0.90%.

The table below shows the expense ratios for different fund types:

In terms of transparency, ETFs disclose their holdings daily. You can always check the ETF’s portfolio structure. Mutual funds typically disclose holdings quarterly, with a 60-day delay. You cannot access real-time details of a mutual fund’s investments.

If you value low costs and high transparency, ETFs better meet your needs. Mutual funds suit investors willing to pay higher fees for active management and professional research.

Basic Concepts

Image Source: pexels

ETF Overview

When investing, you encounter ETFs, which are collective investment vehicles listed on stock exchanges. ETFs allow you to trade them like stocks. ETFs typically adopt passive management strategies, tracking specific market indices. According to U.S. market data, approximately 91% of ETFs are passively managed. ETF shares can be bought or sold during trading hours, with prices fluctuating based on market supply and demand. The table below shows the official definition and key features of ETFs:

ETFs typically track market indices through the following methods:

• Holding all or representative index constituents to achieve full replication or sampling.
• Common indices include the S&P 500, FTSE All-World Index, etc..
• When using optimization strategies, ETFs employ computational models to determine portfolios.

Mutual Fund Overview

You can also choose mutual funds for investment. A mutual fund is an open-end investment company that pools funds from many investors, managed by professional managers. Mutual funds often adopt active management, with fund managers adjusting portfolios based on market analysis. When you purchase or redeem mutual fund shares, the transaction price is based on the day’s net asset value (NAV). The table below shows the official definition and key features of mutual funds:

Mutual fund shares can only be purchased or redeemed through the fund company. When you redeem, the amount you receive depends on the NAV on the redemption day.

Operational Mechanisms

ETFs and mutual funds differ significantly in their operational mechanisms. When you invest in an ETF, authorized participants (APs) handle the creation and redemption of shares, ensuring the ETF’s price closely aligns with its asset value. ETFs are listed on exchanges, offering high liquidity, with prices influenced by market supply and demand. Mutual funds are directly managed by fund companies, and you can only purchase or redeem shares at the NAV after the trading day ends. The table below compares their operational mechanisms:

You can choose the operational mechanisms of ETFs or mutual funds based on your investment needs to achieve your asset allocation goals.

Advantages and Disadvantages Comparison

Costs and Fees

When investing, costs and fees directly impact your long-term returns. ETFs and mutual funds differ significantly in fee structures. ETFs typically adopt passive management, with lower fees. Mutual funds are often actively managed, with higher fees. You can refer to the table below to understand the average expense ratios and annual fees per $10,000 for different fund types:

You’ll notice that ETFs generally have lower fees than mutual funds. ETFs have lower management fees but may incur brokerage commissions during trading. Mutual funds, in addition to management fees, may charge sales loads and redemption fees. The table below further compares their fee structures:

If you pursue low-cost investments, ETFs are more suitable. Mutual funds suit investors willing to pay higher fees for professional management.

Liquidity

Liquidity determines whether you can quickly buy or sell fund shares. ETFs are listed on exchanges, allowing you to trade them like stocks at any time. Mutual funds can only be purchased or redeemed at the NAV after the trading day ends. The table below shows the main differences in liquidity:

When investing in the U.S. market, ETFs’ liquidity advantage is significant. You can adjust your portfolio at any time, flexibly responding to market changes. Mutual funds suit long-term holders who do not need frequent trading.

Information Transparency

Information transparency allows you to stay informed about a fund’s portfolio and risks. ETFs disclose holdings daily, enabling you to view portfolio structures in real-time. Mutual funds typically disclose holdings quarterly, with information potentially delayed by 30 days or more. The table below compares their disclosure frequencies:

• ETFs typically disclose holdings daily, offering real-time transparency.
• Mutual funds usually disclose holdings quarterly, with potential delays.

All ETFs must disclose portfolio holdings daily on their websites, along with historical discount/premium and bid-ask spread information. You can always stay informed about ETF investment dynamics. Mutual funds have lower disclosure frequency, with less transparency compared to ETFs.

Management Style

When choosing funds, the management style determines the investment strategy and risk level. ETFs mostly adopt passive management, tracking specific indices, with fund managers focused on replicating index performance. Mutual funds are often actively managed, with fund managers actively trading securities to outperform the market. The table below summarizes their management styles:

• Actively Managed Mutual Funds: Fund managers use qualitative and quantitative research to flexibly respond to market changes, aiming for above-average returns. Higher fees and trading costs.
• Passively Managed ETFs: Fund managers mainly replicate index performance, using a buy-and-hold strategy, cost-effective with low fees and minimal trading costs.

If you seek professional management and above-average returns, mutual funds are suitable. If you pursue market-average returns and low costs, ETFs are more appropriate.

Tax Treatment

Tax efficiency affects your actual returns. ETFs and mutual funds differ fundamentally in tax treatment. ETFs use an “in-kind” redemption mechanism, distributing fewer capital gains, offering higher tax efficiency. Mutual fund managers frequently trade securities, leading to more capital gains distributions. The table below shows their tax treatment differences:

When investing in the U.S. market, ETFs are generally more tax-efficient than mutual funds. In 2024, only 5% of ETFs distributed capital gains, compared to 43% of mutual funds. This difference is significant, as ETFs help reduce your tax burden and increase net returns.

If you prioritize tax efficiency, ETFs are the better choice. Mutual funds suit long-term investors unconcerned with capital gains distributions.

Market Performance

Image Source: unsplash

Historical Performance

When analyzing ETFs and mutual funds, you should focus on their performance in different market environments. Over the past few years, the U.S. market has experienced multiple fluctuations. You’ll find that defensive ETFs typically perform more steadily during market downturns. These ETFs focus on sectors like utilities and consumer goods, helping you maintain investment stability under economic pressure.

• Defensive ETFs focus on daily necessities, reducing losses during global economic stress.
• During bear markets, you can choose specially designed ETFs to hedge against market downturn risks.
• ETFs offer more tactical options, helping you flexibly manage risks during market fluctuations.
  However, you should note that index ETFs and mutual funds may have concentrated holdings in certain sectors during industry booms. If the technology sector is overweight, a sector downturn can have a larger impact. Mutual funds rely on managers’ active adjustments, potentially offering more resilience in certain market conditions.

Fund Flows

When choosing investment vehicles, fund flow trends reflect investor preferences. Over the past decade, U.S. long-term mutual funds saw $2.9 trillion in net outflows, while ETFs gained $4.5 trillion in net inflows. You can see that more investors are leaning toward ETFs, with the number of actively managed mutual funds declining.

The table below shows fund flows for Q4 2024 and Q1 2025:

You’ll notice that ETFs have attracted over 60% of new capital inflows in the passive investment space. ETFs may offer lower short-term returns during market stress and volatility, but their long-term performance typically outperforms mutual funds. Mutual funds provide liquidity assurance based on NAV, suitable for investors needing stable redemptions.
The performance differences between ETFs and mutual funds reflect investors’ varying needs for flexibility, cost, and long-term returns.

Investor Recommendations

Active vs. Passive Choice

When choosing investment vehicles, you first need to clarify your investment style. If you enjoy making decisions and are willing to spend time researching markets, consider actively managed mutual funds. Fund managers adjust portfolios based on market changes, aiming for above-average returns. If you prefer tracking market-average performance with low costs and high transparency, passively managed ETFs are more suitable. ETFs typically track indices, with low fees, ideal for investors seeking stable long-term growth.

You need to choose active or passive management based on your knowledge level and time commitment. Active management may offer higher returns but comes with higher risks and fees. Passive management is simpler, suitable for most retail investors.

Long-Term vs. Short-Term Needs

Before investing, consider your financial plans. If you have long-term goals, such as retirement savings or education funds, both ETFs and mutual funds can help achieve asset growth. Long-term investments diversify risks, reducing the impact of market fluctuations. If you have short-term needs, such as funds needed within a year, prioritize ETFs with higher liquidity. ETFs can be traded on exchanges at any time, allowing flexible fund adjustments.

• Long-Term Investment: Suitable for both mutual funds and ETFs, focusing on compound growth.
• Short-Term Investment: Prioritize ETFs for quick buying and selling.

Portfolio Allocation

When building a portfolio, combine your risk tolerance and investment goals. You can use ETFs and mutual funds together to diversify across asset classes and market risks. For example, you can use ETFs to allocate to U.S. market index funds and mutual funds for specialized sectors or active strategies. This balances low costs with the benefits of professional management.

Regularly review your portfolio to ensure asset allocation aligns with your risk preferences and goals. Proper allocation helps maintain steady growth across different market conditions.

• You now understand the main differences between ETFs and mutual funds. ETFs suit investors seeking low costs and high transparency. Mutual funds are better for those seeking professional management and active strategies.
• You can choose the right product based on your investment goals and risk tolerance.

Want more practical information? You can check the FAQ to make more informed investment decisions.

FAQ

What are the minimum investment amounts for ETFs and mutual funds?

When investing in ETFs, the minimum amount is typically one share, with prices fluctuating based on the market. For mutual funds, minimum investment amounts vary, with some U.S. market funds requiring USD 500 or more.

Can ETFs be traded in licensed Hong Kong bank accounts?

You can trade U.S. market ETFs through securities accounts with licensed Hong Kong banks. Banks charge trading commissions, priced in USD, so check the relevant service terms in advance.

How long does it take for mutual fund redemption proceeds to arrive?

When redeeming U.S. market mutual funds, funds typically arrive within 1-3 business days after the trading day. The exact time depends on the fund company and bank processing speed.

How are dividends distributed for ETFs and mutual funds?

When holding ETFs or mutual funds, dividends are paid directly to your securities or bank account. U.S. market fund dividends are settled in USD, with distribution frequency determined by the fund.

What taxes apply to investing in ETFs and mutual funds?

When investing in U.S. market ETFs and mutual funds, you must pay capital gains tax and dividend tax. Tax rates vary based on your status and holding period; consult a professional in advance.

You’ve explored the in-depth comparison of ETFs and Mutual Funds. Whichever you choose, securing a flexible, low-cost financial gateway is crucial for realizing your wealth goals.

Cross-border investing, especially in US or Hong Kong stock markets, often brings high remittance fees and non-transparent exchange rates. These hidden costs can severely erode your returns. It’s time to move beyond complex overseas bank accounts and unpredictable transfer times.

Choose BiyaPay to make your fund management as efficient as your investment strategy. We offer real-time exchange rate inquiry and conversion for fiat currencies, with remittance fees as low as 0.5%, ensuring every cross-border transaction is transparent and cost-effective. Even better, BiyaPay allows you to participate in Stocks and H-shares on a single platform without needing an overseas account. Start your next investment phase today—check the Real-time Exchange Rate now, BiyaPay for quick registration, and enjoy the speed of same-day remittance and arrival. Keep more money in your portfolio and less on fees!