How Should Beginner Investors Choose a US Stock Broker? A Practical Comparison Guide for Tiger Brokers and Interactive Brokers

Image Source: unsplash

When choosing a US stock broker, it is recommended to prioritize the following key criteria:

• Fund security, ensuring your funds are protected by institutions like SIPC
• Commission levels, which directly impact your trading costs
• Chinese interface and customer support, helping you operate the platform more effectively
• Support for margin trading and pre-market/after-hours trading to meet various strategy needs
• Membership in FINRA, indicating higher compliance standards

Beginner investors typically prioritize ease of operation and Chinese language support. Active traders focus more on fees and trading features. You should choose a platform based on your own needs, such as Tiger Brokers, which is more user-friendly for Chinese users and suitable for beginners.

Key Points

• When selecting a US stock broker, fund security is the top priority; prioritize platforms regulated and insured by SIPC.
• Beginner investors should choose brokers with simple operations, comprehensive Chinese support, and low account opening thresholds, such as Tiger Brokers.
• Interactive Brokers is suitable for users with larger funds, seeking low commissions, and multi-market investments.
• Pay attention to trading fees and hidden costs, and plan your deposit amounts reasonably to avoid impacting investment returns due to fees.
• Make full use of educational resources and demo accounts provided by brokers to enhance investment skills and reduce operational risks.

Platform Overview

Image Source: pexels

Tiger Brokers Overview

You can view Tiger Brokers as an internet-focused broker. It was founded in 2014 and primarily provides trading services for US and Hong Kong stocks to Chinese investors. Most of Tiger Brokers’ users are young elites under 35 with annual incomes exceeding $40,000. If you prefer trading via mobile or computer and want a user-friendly Chinese interface and community interaction, this platform will suit you better. Tiger Brokers emphasizes global asset allocation, particularly focusing on cross-border investment needs. It initially relied on Interactive Brokers for trade clearing but is now actively obtaining its own licenses to enhance service experience and compliance.

Tip: Tiger Brokers’ underlying trading channels and fund custody primarily rely on Interactive Brokers. Your funds are custodied through Interactive Brokers at major banks like Citibank in the US, ensuring security.

Interactive Brokers Overview

Interactive Brokers (IB) is a large, comprehensive broker. You can use it to invest in US stocks, Hong Kong stocks, ETFs, options, and other products. Interactive Brokers serves a wide range of clients, including individual investors, professional traders, and institutional clients. It provides underlying trading channels and clearing services for multiple brokers, including Tiger Brokers. If you seek lower trading costs, a wider range of investment products, and more professional trading tools, Interactive Brokers is a good choice. Interactive Brokers is regulated by multiple countries, and client funds are similarly protected by institutions like SIPC.

Note: When you open an account with Tiger Brokers, your actual account and funds are held by Interactive Brokers, enjoying the same level of fund security as direct Interactive Brokers clients.

Account Opening Requirements

Minimum Deposit

When choosing a US stock broker, the minimum deposit requirement is an important factor. Both Tiger Brokers and Interactive Brokers are relatively friendly to beginner investors. You can refer to the table below to quickly understand their minimum deposit policies:

If you only want to experience US stock trading, you can deposit a small amount. Tiger Brokers allows zero-fund account opening, but for day trading, your account net value must reach $25,000. Interactive Brokers has no strict deposit requirement for regular stock accounts, but for margin or options trading, it’s recommended to prepare $100-$300 or more. You should plan your deposit amount based on your investment strategy and risk tolerance.

Account Opening Process

When opening an account, the ease of the process and approval speed are equally important. Tiger Brokers has a relatively simple account opening process, suitable for investors from mainland China, Hong Kong, Macao, and Taiwan. You only need to prepare an ID, phone number, and bank card, and follow these steps:

1. Register your phone number and download the Tiger Brokers app.
2. Log into the app and upload your ID and bank card information.
3. Follow the instructions to fill in personal details and submit the application.
4. Wait for approval, typically completed within 2-3 business days.

You will receive a notification of the approval result, and once approved, you can deposit funds and start trading. Interactive Brokers has a more complex account opening process. You need to fill in detailed information online and upload proof of identity and address. The approval time is generally 2-5 business days. Some account types may require higher deposit thresholds. You should consider your readiness to provide materials and the convenience of the process when choosing.

Friendly Reminder: Tiger Brokers supports ID-based account opening, but due to changing compliance policies, new users from mainland China cannot currently open accounts directly. Investors from Hong Kong, Macao, and Taiwan should stay updated on the latest policy changes.

Trading Fees

Image Source: unsplash

Tiger Brokers Fees

When using Tiger Brokers for US stock trading, you need to pay attention to commissions and platform fees. Tiger Brokers’ US stock commission is $0.0039 per share, with a minimum of $0.99 per trade. The platform also charges a minimum $1 platform fee, so your minimum total cost per trade is 1.99](https://cj.sina.cn/articles/view/7854346438/1d427d0c60010178e6). For Hong Kong stock trading, the commission is 0.029%, with a minimum of HK. For Hong Kong stock trading, the commission is 0.029%, with a minimum of HK$7, plus an HK$8 platform fee, totaling a minimum of HK$15. Singapore stocks and US stock options have corresponding minimum fees. You can refer to the table below to quickly understand the minimum trading fees for different markets:

You should note that during certain promotional periods, Tiger Brokers may offer commission discounts, but in the long term, its fee level is moderately low in the market. If you trade frequently, cumulative fees may have a noticeable impact.

Tip: Tiger Brokers’ fee structure is simple and clear, suitable for beginner investors. You can check detailed fee breakdowns for each trade via the app to avoid confusion from hidden costs.

Interactive Brokers Fees

Interactive Brokers is known for its low costs, ideal for investors seeking maximum fee advantages. For US stock trading, the commission is $1 per 200 shares, averaging $0.005 per share. The minimum fee per trade is typically lower than Tiger Brokers. Interactive Brokers also supports more trading products with a flexible and transparent fee structure. If you engage in high-frequency or large-volume trading, Interactive Brokers’ low commission advantage becomes more significant.

You can quickly understand Interactive Brokers’ main fee advantages through the following list:

1. US stock trading commissions as low as $1 per 200 shares, ideal for large-volume or high-frequency trading.
2. Low platform fees, with some account types even exempt from platform fees.
3. Support for multi-market and multi-product trading, with overall fee levels leading among global brokers.

When using Interactive Brokers, you can also access rich professional tools and real-time data services, which are highly attractive to professional investors.

Note: You need to use an offshore IP to access the Interactive Brokers platform. Some features and services may have restrictions for Chinese users.

Margin Interest Rates

If you need margin trading, margin interest rates are a key consideration. Tiger Brokers’ margin interest rates generally range from 3.90% to 4.80%. You can check the current rate in real-time via the app. Public information on Interactive Brokers’ margin rates is not explicitly disclosed, but based on general market feedback, their rates are typically below the industry average, especially suitable for professional investors with leverage needs.

When choosing a broker, you should compare the rates and service details of different platforms based on your fund size and margin needs.

Friendly Reminder: Regardless of the broker you choose, it’s recommended to understand all fee details in advance, including commissions, platform fees, margin interest, and potential hidden costs. This helps you better control investment costs and improve overall returns.

Service Experience

Platform Usability

When choosing a US stock broker, the platform’s usability directly impacts your investment experience. Tiger Brokers has a clean interface design and a straightforward operation process. You can quickly complete account opening, deposits, and trading via the mobile app or web platform. The platform supports one-click trading, smart search, and personalized market data feeds. If you’re new to US stock investing, you can get started quickly. Interactive Brokers offers a powerful trading terminal, including web, desktop, and mobile versions. You can use rich charting tools and customizable indicators. Interactive Brokers’ interface is more geared toward professional users with more feature options. If you have some investment experience, you can leverage these tools for in-depth analysis. For beginners, Interactive Brokers’ operation process may feel complex and require time to adapt.

Tip: If you prioritize ease of operation and a user-friendly interface, consider Tiger Brokers first. If you need advanced trading features and multi-market support, try Interactive Brokers’ professional platform.

Chinese Language Support

When using a US stock broker, the coverage and quality of Chinese language support are crucial. Tiger Brokers offers a full Chinese interface and Chinese customer support. You can access Chinese help documents, market insights, and operation guides directly in the app. Interactive Brokers also supports a Chinese interface, but some professional tools and advanced features are primarily in English. When facing complex issues, you may need to refer to English materials or wait for Chinese customer support responses.

The table below compares the two brokers’ performance in Chinese language support and related experiences:

You can see that Tiger Brokers has an advantage in Chinese language support and localized experience. If you prefer Chinese operations, Tiger Brokers will feel more comfortable. While Interactive Brokers offers Chinese support, it’s more suited for investors with some English proficiency and professional needs.

Customer Support

When you encounter issues, the response speed and professionalism of customer support directly affect your investment confidence. Tiger Brokers provides 24/7 online Chinese customer support. You can quickly contact support via in-app chat, phone, or email. Most common issues can be resolved in a short time. Interactive Brokers also offers multi-channel support, including online tickets, phone, and email. If you use Chinese support, you may experience longer wait times, especially during peak periods. Interactive Brokers’ support team is highly professional and can address complex trading and compliance issues. If you have multi-market investment needs, you can receive comprehensive technical support.

Friendly Reminder: When choosing a broker, prioritize customer support response speed and communication convenience. If you value Chinese support and instant communication, Tiger Brokers is more suitable. If you seek professional depth and multi-market support, Interactive Brokers’ customer support is also reliable.

Fund Security

Regulatory Compliance

When choosing a US stock broker, regulatory compliance is the most critical safety assurance. You can rest assured that both Interactive Brokers and Tiger Brokers are subject to strict financial regulation.

• Interactive Brokers holds multiple US financial licenses and is fully regulated by the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). It also has licenses for brokerage, investment banking, registered investment advisory, self-clearing, and futures.
• Tiger Brokers, through its New Zealand-registered TBNZ company, is regulated by the New Zealand Financial Markets Authority (FMA). When investing in the US, Tiger Brokers’ operations are also regulated by the US SEC and CFTC.
• When investing in Hong Kong, Tiger Brokers previously obtained relevant licenses approved by the Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) through acquisitions, but its Hong Kong stock business primarily relies on Interactive Brokers’ clearing services.
• Interactive Brokers is currently not permitted to directly conduct business in mainland China.

You can assess a broker’s compliance through this regulatory information. Multiple regulatory frameworks provide greater assurance for your investments.

Fund Protection

When opening an account and trading, your primary concern is whether your funds are secure. When you open an account with Interactive Brokers, client funds are strictly segregated from the company’s own funds and custodied at major banks like Citibank in the US. When you open an account with Tiger Brokers, your funds are also custodied by Interactive Brokers, enjoying the same security standards.

• Each of your accounts is covered by SIPC protection up to $500,000, with the cash portion also eligible for FDIC protection up to $250,000.
• In the event of a broker’s bankruptcy, SIPC will compensate for losses, excluding investment losses.
• You can also receive up to $30 million in commercial insurance compensation (currently $900,000), further enhancing fund security.
• When opening an account with Tiger Brokers, client funds are held in personal custodial accounts at Citibank in the US, and the broker cannot misappropriate your assets.
• When opening an account with Interactive Brokers, your funds are similarly protected by SIPC and additional insurance.

Tip: When choosing a broker, prioritize measures like fund segregation, SIPC protection, and additional insurance to significantly reduce fund risks and boost investment confidence.

Investment Products

US Stock Trading

When choosing a broker, you’ll first focus on the variety and functionality of US stock trading. Both platforms support stocks and options trading in the US market. You can refer to the table below to quickly understand their coverage of major investment products:

You can see that both platforms meet your basic investment needs for US stocks, Hong Kong stocks, ETFs, and options. If you want to invest in more products, Interactive Brokers offers a broader selection. You can invest in over 150 global markets with one account, including stocks, options, futures, ETFs, cryptocurrencies, bonds, and funds. Interactive Brokers also supports multi-currency trading and funding in 27 currencies, facilitating global asset allocation.

Multi-Market Support

If you aim for global diversified investments, a platform’s multi-market support is critical. Interactive Brokers covers over 150 global markets, supporting stocks, options, futures, forex, bonds, funds, and other asset classes. You can easily invest in major markets like the US, Europe, and Asia with one account. Interactive Brokers also offers one of the largest mutual fund marketplaces globally, covering multiple well-known brands.

Tiger Brokers is also actively pursuing an internationalization strategy. You can open accounts and trade in markets like the US, Australia, Hong Kong, Singapore, and New Zealand. The Singapore market stands out, with diverse products like fund supermarkets, Hong Kong stock options, and US OTC markets, making it the internet broker with the broadest market coverage and most trading products locally. You can also enjoy an integrated app experience combining news, market data, trading, and social features to enhance your investment experience.

Tip: If you seek extensive product variety and global asset allocation, Interactive Brokers is more suitable. If you value multi-market coverage and localized services, Tiger Brokers is also worth considering.

Recommendations for Different Audiences

Beginner Investors

If you’re new to US stock investing, prioritize platform security and ease of operation. You can follow these steps to gradually select a suitable broker:

1. Fund Security: Choose brokers regulated by FINRA and SIPC to ensure your funds are protected up to $500,000.
2. Commissions and Fees: Pay attention to minimum deposit requirements and monthly minimum commissions. Some platforms, like Interactive Brokers, may not be beginner-friendly for small accounts due to a minimum $10 monthly commission.
3. Chinese Customer Support: If you prefer Chinese communication, 24/7 Chinese support will make you feel more at ease. Some platforms have limited Chinese support hours, which may delay issue resolution.
4. Platform Ease of Use: Beginners are better suited to platforms with simple interfaces and intuitive operations. Complex professional tools may feel overwhelming.
5. Educational Resources and Community Support: Rich learning materials and investment communities can help you grow quickly.

If you have limited funds and value Chinese support and educational resources, choose a platform with low account opening thresholds and simple operations. This allows you to get started quickly and reduce trial-and-error costs.

Friendly Reminder: Before opening an account, try demo accounts to familiarize yourself with platform features and avoid losses due to operational errors.

Advanced and Professional Users

If you have some investment experience or larger funds, consider platforms with richer features and lower fees. The table below compares suitable brokers for different investor types:

If you seek low commissions, diverse investment products, and professional trading tools, choose Interactive Brokers. You can invest in global markets with one account and enjoy lower trading costs. If you have large funds and strong professional needs, a professional broker’s multi-market support and efficient risk management will suit you better.

Tip: When choosing a broker, consider your fund size, investment experience, and trading frequency for a rational decision, and avoid blindly following trends.

Notes

Hidden Fees

When choosing a US stock broker, don’t focus only on surface commissions. Many platforms have hidden fees, such as account management fees, data subscription fees, deposit/withdrawal handling fees, and currency exchange fees. If you don’t trade for a long time, some brokers may charge inactivity fees. When using margin trading, interest is also a significant cost. It’s recommended to carefully read the fee disclosure before opening an account and regularly check statements to avoid increased costs from overlooked small fees.

Tip: You can find the “Fee Details” page on the broker’s app or website to understand all potential fees in advance.

Deposits and Withdrawals

When depositing or withdrawing funds with a US stock broker, the primary method is wire transfer. Both Tiger Brokers and Interactive Brokers require you to use a bank account in your name. You should note the processing time and fees. Different banks have varying processing speeds, with Hong Kong banks typically being faster. The table below compares key deposit/withdrawal details:

When transferring funds, verify the recipient information to avoid rejections or delays due to errors.

Common Misconceptions

When investing in US stocks, you may encounter some misconceptions. For example, assuming all brokers support direct RMB deposits, when in reality, you can only use USD, HKD, or other foreign currencies. You may overlook withdrawal fees and exchange rate losses. You might also mistakenly believe that a broker’s bankruptcy leads to total fund loss, whereas SIPC and additional insurance provide protection. Before opening an account and trading, it’s recommended to review official guidelines to avoid unnecessary losses due to incomplete information.

Friendly Reminder: If you have questions, promptly contact the broker’s customer support or check the help center to enhance your investment confidence.

When choosing a US stock broker, you should align with your investment goals and risk tolerance, make rational decisions, and avoid focusing solely on low commissions. Brokers with strong brand reputations ensure fund security, and services and educational resources are equally important. It’s recommended to stay updated on fee structures and policy changes, leverage financial news and investment communities to continuously improve knowledge, and adjust investment strategies in time to ensure smooth and secure investing.

FAQ

What documents are required to open an account with Tiger Brokers or Interactive Brokers?

You need to prepare an ID, a valid phone number, and a bank card in your name. During account opening, the platform will require you to upload ID photos and fill in personal information. In some cases, Interactive Brokers may also require proof of address.

What should I pay attention to for deposits and withdrawals with US stock brokers?

You can only use a bank account in your name for wire transfers. It’s recommended to prioritize Hong Kong banks for faster processing. USD exchange rates are based on the bank’s daily rate. Verify recipient information carefully to avoid transfer failures.

What are the main fees for trading US stocks?

You need to pay commissions, platform fees, and potential margin interest. Tiger Brokers’ minimum per trade is $1.99 for US stocks, while Interactive Brokers is lower. You should also note currency exchange fees and deposit/withdrawal handling fees, with specific amounts based on platform announcements.

Are my funds secure?

Your funds are custodied by Interactive Brokers and covered by SIPC protection up to $500,000. The cash portion is also eligible for FDIC protection up to $250,000. The broker cannot misappropriate your funds. You can check your account balance and fund details at any time.

Are there trading restrictions for new US stock investors?

If your account net value is below $25,000, you can only conduct up to three day trades per week. You must comply with US securities market regulations. It’s recommended to review platform rules in advance and plan your trading strategy accordingly.

This article provides a detailed comparison of Tiger Brokers and Interactive Brokers, from account opening and fees to services and security. You may have found that no matter which platform you choose, fund exchange and transfers remain a key challenge when investing overseas. High bank wire fees, long processing times, and complex currency conversion procedures can all affect your investment efficiency and experience.

Now, you can choose a simpler and more efficient financial channel. BiyaPay is built for global investors, offering a one-stop, seamless cross-border financial service. We support the convenient exchange between various fiat and digital currencies and provide a real-time exchange rate query, so you can always catch the best conversion times. Our service, with remittance fees as low as 0.5% and same-day delivery, significantly reduces your transaction costs and time. What’s more, we enable you to invest in both U.S. and Hong Kong stocks from a single platform without needing a complicated overseas bank account. Say goodbye to complexity and embrace efficiency. Register with BiyaPay today to easily begin your global investment journey.