US Stock Account Selection Guide: A Full Analysis of the Pros and Cons of Tiger Brokers and Fidelity

Image Source: unsplash

For smaller budgets and seamless multi-market trading, Tiger Brokers is ideal. For substantial capital and long-term investing, Fidelity excels. The Cross-Border Wealth Connect 2.0 has boosted Chinese investors’ access to U.S. stocks, with active fund flows reflecting strong demand. Tiger Brokers attracts active traders with low fees and tech-driven platforms, while Fidelity serves conservative, long-term investors with comprehensive services. Choose based on your capital, trading habits, and residency.

Key Points

• Tiger Brokers suits smaller budgets, low fees, and multi-market trading, with easy signup and Chinese support.
• Fidelity fits wealthier, long-term investors seeking professional services and high security.
• Focus on trading commissions, margin rates, signup conditions, and platform experience when choosing.
• Non-U.S. residents find Tiger Brokers’ online signup simpler; Fidelity’s process is complex with stricter requirements.
• Beginners should prioritize user-friendly interfaces and educational resources; active traders need low costs and flexible leverage.

Core Factors for Choosing a U.S. Stock Account

Selecting a U.S. stock broker requires evaluating key factors, as platforms differ significantly.

Fees and Commissions

Trading fees are a primary concern:

1. Trading Costs: Some brokers charge fixed per-trade fees, others per share. Compare for cost efficiency.
2. Platform Stability and Features: Reliable platforms with real-time data and fast execution enhance trading.
3. Other Fees: Watch for funding, withdrawal, or account management fees to avoid surprises.

Signup Conditions

Signup requirements vary:

Some require only a bank card, others need passports or address proof.

Service Experience

Service quality impacts long-term use. Consider customer support, platform usability, and educational resources:

• Tiger Brokers offers free Level 2 U.S. stock quotes for funded accounts, covering pre-market, regular, and after-hours trading.
• Its platform is stable, with a simple, beginner-friendly interface.
• Fidelity provides extensive investment products, intuitive UI, and robust support, ideal for beginners and casual investors.

Unique Features

Features enhance efficiency:

• Multi-Market Trading: Tiger Brokers supports U.S., Hong Kong, and China A-shares via a single account.
• Online Signup: Tiger Brokers requires only an ID, no in-person or video verification.
• Education: Tiger’s stock academy and events boost knowledge.
• Cash Management: Some platforms offer ~4.07% cash yield (source), with flexible withdrawals.
• IPO Access: Tiger Brokers enables one-click U.S. IPO subscriptions.

Evaluate fees, signup, services, and features to find your ideal broker.

Account Types and Signup Conditions

Supported Account Types

Tiger Brokers offers Standard and Global accounts (source):

1. Global accounts allow shorting; Standard accounts limit shorting to S&P 500 stocks.
2. Standard accounts support futures; Global accounts do not.
3. Standard accounts have no minimum for unlimited T+0 trading; Global accounts require $25,000.
4. Standard accounts offer 2x leverage; Global accounts 4x.

Additional accounts include margin, options, and futures (optional). Tiger auto-generates W-8BEN forms for tax-exempt U.S. profits. Fidelity’s account options are more limited, primarily serving U.S. residents.

Non-U.S. Resident Signup

Tiger Brokers supports Chinese investors with easy online signup, no U.S. ID required (source). Fidelity caters to U.S. residents, with complex processes for international clients. Tiger is more accessible for Chinese investors.

Tip: Tiger’s system auto-detects identity for non-U.S. resident declarations, simplifying signup.

Signup Process

Tiger Brokers’ signup is straightforward:

Submit ID, debit card, and overseas bank card. Optional proof of other accounts aids verification. Register, download the app, verify, and fund via overseas card to activate. Fidelity requires passports, address proof, and overseas cards, with longer reviews. Tiger offers a friendlier experience for Chinese investors.

Commissions and Margin Rates

Image Source: unsplash

Trading Commissions

Commissions impact costs (source):

Tiger suits small budgets and frequent traders; Fidelity’s zero commissions favor long-term, larger investors.

Margin Rates

Margin rates affect borrowing costs. Tiger’s rates range from 6%–8%, varying by market and account type. Fidelity’s rates are 8%–10%, lower for larger balances. High-net-worth investors benefit more from Fidelity’s scale-based rates.

Tip: Check broker websites for current margin rates, as they fluctuate annually.

Other Fees

Tiger may incur funding fees via Hong Kong banks ($10–$20). Fidelity’s zero-commission trades exclude fees for withdrawals or paper statements. Review fee schedules to avoid surprises (source).

Consider commissions, margin rates, and fees based on your trading style and capital.

Service and Platform Experience

Image Source: pexels

Ease of Use

Tiger Brokers offers seamless mobile/web signup, trading, and fund management with a clear, Chinese-supported interface, ideal for beginners. Fidelity’s stable, feature-rich platform suits experienced users comfortable with English. Tiger’s funding is faster via Hong Kong banks; Fidelity favors U.S. accounts, with slower international transfers.

Customer Service

Tiger provides 24/7 Chinese support via chat, phone, or email, plus educational content. Fidelity offers professional phone, email, and online support, with personalized advisory services. Choose based on language and service needs.

Multi-Market Trading

Tiger supports U.S., Hong Kong, and A-shares with integrated analytics and smart orders. Fidelity focuses on U.S. markets, offering extensive U.S. products and research. Tiger suits global diversification; Fidelity excels for U.S.-focused investors.

Unique Features and Incentives

Debit Card and IPO Access

Tiger offers virtual debit cards for flexible spending and one-click U.S. IPO subscriptions. Fidelity provides physical debit cards linked to U.S. accounts and IPO access with high asset thresholds ($500,000, 36 trades/year). Tiger is more accessible for IPOs and card use.

Signup Incentives

Signup bonuses (source) vary:

Tiger and Fidelity bonuses depend on promotions; check announcements. Verify deposit thresholds and timelines.

Activity Continuity

Tiger’s high user activity drives biweekly updates, enhancing features and engagement (source). Fidelity updates less frequently, prioritizing stability for long-term investors. Tiger suits dynamic users; Fidelity fits steady investors.

Account Choice Recommendations

Beginner Investors

Focus on:

1. Fees: Tiger’s low commissions suit small, frequent trades; Fidelity’s zero commissions fit larger, infrequent trades.
2. Usability: Tiger’s Chinese interface is beginner-friendly; Fidelity’s intuitive for English users.
3. Interface: Both offer clear layouts.
4. Tools/Resources: Fidelity excels in education and analytics.
5. Safety: Both are regulated with strong encryption.

Choose user-friendly, educational platforms.

Frequent Traders

Tiger’s $0.01/share, min $2.99 commission (source) and flexible leverage suit active traders. Fidelity’s $8.95/trade is costlier. Tiger is better for cost-conscious trading.

Margin Needs

Tiger’s 6%–8% margin rates and flexible leverage fit smaller budgets. Fidelity’s 8%–10% rates favor larger accounts. Match rates to your capital and risk tolerance.

Non-U.S. Residents

Fidelity restricts non-U.S. residents, requiring complex documentation (source). Tiger’s Hong Kong accounts simplify signup with Chinese support, though limited to Hong Kong bank transfers (source). Prepare Hong Kong cards for Tiger.

Long-Term Investors

Consider:

1. Customer Service: Fidelity’s responsive team excels.
2. Safety: Both are SEC-regulated.
3. Research: Fidelity’s robust analytics aid long-term decisions.
4. Interface: Tiger’s Chinese support enhances accessibility.
5. Tax: Both assist with W-8BEN to avoid double taxation.

Fidelity suits long-term, high-capital investors.

Pros and Cons Summary

Tiger Brokers

Pros:

• Low fees: $0.0039/share, min $0.99, competitive for frequent traders.
• Multi-market: U.S., Hong Kong, Australia, New Zealand.
• Fast signup: ~1 hour, Chinese-friendly.
• Intuitive platform, Chinese interface (source).
• Diverse products: Stocks, options, ETFs.
• Active community for insights.
• Low margin rates: 3.5%–5%.

Cons:

• Slower customer support for urgent issues.
• Some features require experience.
• Limited Hong Kong product range.
• Unclear fee explanations.
• No Hong Kong commission waivers.

Tiger suits cost-conscious, multi-market traders.

Fidelity

Pros:

• Large analyst team for in-depth research.
• Professional 24/7 support.
• Extensive U.S. products and planning tools.
• Strong brand, outperforming funds.
• High security, SEC-regulated.

Cons:

• High signup threshold (source).
• IPO access limited ($500,000, 36 trades/year).
• Fewer internal FOFs, some ethical risks.
• High analyst/manager turnover.
• Complex international signup.

Fidelity fits wealthy, long-term investors.

Selection Guide

Beginners or small-budget investors should choose Tiger Brokers for low costs and ease. Wealthy, long-term investors benefit from Fidelity’s services. Tiger offers innovative IPO services; Fidelity excels in stability.

• Capital size narrows broker options.
• Investment goals shape platform choice.
• Residency ensures compliant signup.

FAQ

What documents are needed for Tiger Brokers signup?

ID, China “62” debit card, Hong Kong/overseas bank card, phone. W-8BEN auto-generated.

Can non-U.S. residents use Fidelity?

Yes, but complex: requires passport, address proof, overseas bank card, and longer reviews.

What funding options do Tiger Brokers and Fidelity offer?

USD transfers via Hong Kong banks (Tiger) or U.S. accounts (Fidelity). Fees: $10–$20.

Are accounts safe?

Both are regulated (Fidelity: SEC; Tiger: Hong Kong). Monitor account security.

What markets does Tiger Brokers support?

U.S., Hong Kong, A-shares (Shanghai/Shenzhen), Australia, New Zealand.

When comparing Tiger Brokers and Fidelity, it’s clear that both have their advantages, yet a common pain point remains: complex fund transfers. The article repeatedly emphasizes that for non-U.S. residents, funding largely depends on Hong Kong bank transfers. This means you not only need to open an overseas account but also face high wire fees, non-transparent exchange rate losses, and long settlement times. These cumbersome steps undoubtedly become obstacles on your path to U.S. stock investment.

BiyaPay is built to solve these cross-border financial pain points, providing you with a smoother and more cost-effective investment channel. We support the conversion between various fiat and digital currencies, allowing you to easily manage global assets, and offer a real-time exchange rate query feature to ensure you always get the best rates. Most importantly, we provide remittance fees as low as 0.5% with same-day delivery, significantly reducing your transaction costs and time. Now, you can invest in both U.S. and Hong Kong stocks on a single platform without needing a complex overseas account. Say goodbye to cross-border payment hassles and start your efficient financial journey now. Register with BiyaPay and make your fund management as smooth as your trading.